September 2018 – This Had Oscar Buzz

014 – The Door in the Floor

This week’s episode is the sound of something trying to not make a sound. It’s our first failed Oscar buzz movie that we genuinely love and it’s 2004’s The Door in the Floor. Adapted from the first segment of John Irving’s A Widow for One Year, this film stars Jeff Bridges as a grieving novelist, Kim Basinger as his estranged wife, and Jon Foster as the young student spending the summer between them.

The Door in the Floor also introduced us to Elle Fanning and gave us what might be the best adaptation of Irving’s work. The film feels like a crucial stop on the path to Bridges’ eventual Oscar for Crazy Heart, and is best remembered for his performance. Or maybe, it’s just his muumuu caftan. Listen along as we obsess over the lore of Focus Features, gush over its underappreciated and oft-repurposed score, and gasp over the film’s cameo from a beloved Tony winner.

Podcast: Play in new window | Download

Subscribe: Google Podcasts | RSS

TIFF ’18 BONUS – We’re Far From the Scotia Now

We’re taking a break from our usual dives into thwarted Oscar buzz this week and taking a look at all the films we saw at the Toronto International Film Festival! Not only are Joe and Chris in the same room for once, but we also have our very first guests: The Film Experience’s Nathaniel Rogers and Film Comment’s Nick Davis!

Though none of us saw the eventual winner of that bellwether of Oscar buzz, Grolsch People’s Choice Award, Green Book (from Osmosis Jones director Peter Farrelly), we still have lots to discuss regarding Oscar and festival ephemera. Listen along as the four of us dive off the deep end to talk our favorites of the festival, our disappointments, and what at the festival we think will lose Oscar steam. Topics include: the ubiquitous love for A Star is Born, Juliette Binoche’s High Life sex braid, and a stacked Foreign Language field led by Alfonso Cuarón’s Roma.

Podcast: Play in new window | Download

Subscribe: Google Podcasts | RSS

013 – It’s Complicated

Close your eyes. Picture the movie about kitchens you’ve always wanted. Now open them. Is Alec Baldwin blowing pot smoke into your face? That’s kind of what it’s like to experience the 2009 romantic comedy It’s Complicated, from celebrated (and beleaguered) director Nancy Meyers.

Since Oscar buzz follows Meryl Streep around like a heartsick ex-husband wherever she goes, this was a no-brainer of a selection for This Had Oscar Buzz. Join us for discussion of Steve Martin’s banjo commitments, the utility of Mary Kay Place as a gal pal, and whether John Krasinski was at one point a gay assistant.

Join Chris, Joe, and two very flirty Jack Ryans for our episode on It’s Complicated.

Podcast: Play in new window | Download

Subscribe: Google Podcasts | RSS

012 – An Unfinished Life

This week’s episode takes you back to September 2005, when the exit of the Weinsteins from Miramax resulted in a fire sale of delayed releases finally arriving in theatres to the most modest of fanfares. Least trumpeted of all was An Unfinished Life, starring Robert Redford, Jennifer Lopez, and Morgan Freeman.

Here we have a film to fill your This Had Oscar Buzz bingo card: Lasse Hallström. An adaptation of a book about a grieving family. Scar makeup of debatable quality. A bear shows up. And of course, the oh-so-trustworthy source of test screening reactions from online message boards building up our hopes of a Camryn Manheim nomination.

What makes a life “unfinished”? As we discuss this week, it might just be having a name like Griff, living in the generalized American west, and (our favorite) winning an award we have never heard of before!

Podcast: Play in new window | Download

Subscribe: Google Podcasts | RSS